首个医疗影像分割联邦学习基准,助力隐私保护下的精准协作分析
FL-MedSegBench: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Federated Learning on Medical Image Segmentation
- 构建涵盖10种模态的9个分割任务,覆盖2D/3D临床真实数据
- 个性化联邦方法(如FedBN)在准确率与鲁棒性上显著优于通用方法
- 揭示通信频率降低时方法的稳定性,为临床部署提供实证指导
联邦学习(FL)为无需共享原始数据的医疗影像协同分析提供了隐私保护范式。然而,缺乏标准化的医学图像分割评估基准,制约了对各类联邦学习方法的公平、全面评价。为此,我们提出FL-MedSegBench,首个面向医学图像分割的联邦学习综合基准。该基准涵盖10种成像模态、9项分割任务,支持2D与3D格式,具有真实临床异质性。我们系统评估了8种通用联邦学习(gFL)与5种个性化联邦学习(pFL)方法在分割精度、公平性、通信效率、收敛行为及未见领域泛化能力等多个维度的表现。大量实验揭示:(i) 个性化方法(如含客户端批量归一化的方法,例如FedBN)持续优于通用方法;(ii) 无单一方法在所有数据集上通杀,性能依赖数据集特性;(iii) 通信频率降低时,基于归一化的个性化方法表现出显著鲁棒性;(iv) Fairness评估发现Ditto和FedRDN等方法能有效保护表现较差的客户端;(v) 方法在未见领域的泛化能力与其在参与客户端上的整体表现密切相关。我们将开源工具包以促进可复现研究,加速临床可用的联邦学习解决方案落地,并提供基于实证的部署建议。代码已公开于 https://github.com/meiluzhu/FL-MedSegBench。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Federated learning (FL) offers a privacy-preserving paradigm for collaborative medical image analysis without sharing raw data. However, the absence of standardized benchmarks for medical image segmentation hinders fair and comprehensive evaluation of FL methods. To address this gap, we introduce FL-MedSegBench, the first comprehensive benchmark for federated learning on medical image segmentation. Our benchmark encompasses nine segmentation tasks across ten imaging modalities, covering both 2D and 3D formats with realistic clinical heterogeneity. We systematically evaluate eight generic FL (gFL) and five personalized FL (pFL) methods across multiple dimensions: segmentation accuracy, fairness, communication efficiency, convergence behavior, and generalization to unseen domains. Extensive experiments reveal several key insights: (i) pFL methods, particularly those with client-specific batch normalization (\textit{e.g.}, FedBN), consistently outperform generic approaches; (ii) No single method universally dominates, with performance being dataset-dependent; (iii) Communication frequency analysis shows normalization-based personalization methods exhibit remarkable robustness to reduced communication frequency; (iv) Fairness evaluation identifies methods like Ditto and FedRDN that protect underperforming clients; (v) A method's generalization to unseen domains is strongly tied to its ability to perform well across participating clients. We will release an open-source toolkit to foster reproducible research and accelerate clinically applicable FL solutions, providing empirically grounded guidelines for real-world clinical deployment. The source code is available at https://github.com/meiluzhu/FL-MedSegBench.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。