通过验证推理过程而非答案,解决模型自提升训练中的错误累积问题。
Reliable Self-Improvement Training by Verifying Reasoning, Not Just Answers
- 用符号计算验证每一步推理,而非仅看最终答案是否正确。
- 在GSM8K上5轮自提升后准确率从80.5%提升至91.0%,显著优于基线。
- 适合需要长期可靠自我改进的AI系统,尤其在可自动化验证的领域。
自提升训练让模型从自身生成的解答中学习,有望实现持续能力提升,但普遍存在错误累积导致性能停滞或下降的问题。我们发现,现有基于最终答案正确性的筛选标准会保留那些答案正确但推理错误的样本(如侥幸猜对),污染训练数据。为此提出验证式自提升(VSI)框架,通过符号计算库sympy重新计算算术步骤、检查中间一致性并施加领域约束,以结构完整性作为数据保留依据。在GSM8K数据集上,使用Qwen3-4B-Thinking模型进行5轮自提升实验表明,VSI拒绝了约34%的正确答案样本,有效剔除侥幸猜对的情况。该更干净的训练信号使准确率持续提升,从80.5%增至91.0%;而仅依赖结果验证的方案出现瓶颈,未验证训练则迅速崩溃。进一步将VSI判断转为偏好对(DPO),使模型区分合理推理与侥幸答案的能力提升,奖励准确率从46%升至63%。VSI提供了一种简单、可复现的鲁棒自提升方法,适用于可自动化推理验证的场景。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Self-improvement training, where models learn from self-generated solutions, promises sustained capability gains but suffers from a pervasive failure mode: across multiple rounds, compounding reasoning errors cause accuracy to stall or degrade. We trace this drift to standard filtering criteria that retain solutions based solely on final answer correctness, which lets lucky guesses (correct answers with flawed reasoning) contaminate the training data. We propose Verified Self-Improvement (VSI), a framework that conditions data retention on step-level structural integrity rather than just the final output. VSI validates solutions by recomputing arithmetic steps via a computer-algebra library (sympy), checking intermediate consistency, and enforcing domain constraints. Evaluating VSI on GSM8K with Qwen3-4B-Thinking across 5 rounds of self-improvement against four baselines (no verification, outcome verification, majority voting, and VSI with DPO) shows that VSI rejects approximately 34% of correct-answer solutions, successfully isolating lucky guesses. This cleaner training signal drives sustained accuracy gains across all rounds (80.5% to 91.0%), whereas outcome verification plateaus and unverified training collapses. Finally, converting VSI checks into DPO preference pairs trains the model to distinguish sound reasoning from lucky answers, boosting reward accuracy from 46% to 63%. VSI offers a simple, reproducible recipe for robust self-improvement whenever automated reasoning checks are available.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。