arXiv:2604.03853cs.LG2026-04

对比两种微生物组计数模型,发现样本量越大越该用更复杂的模型。

Understanding When Poisson Log-Normal Models Outperform Penalized Poisson Regression for Microbiome Count Data

  • 统一用留一分类别验证框架比较PLN与惩罚泊松回归
  • 样本量大时PLN预测误差降低最高达38%,胜出关键看样本/物种比
  • 适合做微生物群落预测或网络推断的研究者参考

多变量计数模型因能捕捉潜在依赖关系而被广泛应用,但研究者缺乏选择依据。本文在统一的留一类别预测与三折样本交叉验证框架下,基于20个真实微生物组数据集(样本数32至18,270,物种数24至257)比较PLN与GLMNet(Poisson)在计数预测上的表现;同时在五个公开数据集上评估PLNNetwork与GLMNet(Poisson)在微生物相互作用推断中的性能。结果显示,多数情况下PLN在预测上优于GLMNet(Poisson),最高可降低38%的泊松偏差;胜出的主要预测因子是样本-物种比,平均绝对相关性为最强次级信号,过分散程度亦具预测价值。对于网络推断,PLNNetwork在广义无向交互任务中表现最佳,而GLMNet(Poisson)更契合局部或方向性效应。结果为生物计数建模中选择复杂多变量模型还是简化惩罚泊松回归提供了实证指导。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Multivariate count models are often justified by their ability to capture latent dependence, but researchers receive little guidance on when this added structure improves on simpler penalized marginal Poisson regression. We study this question using real microbiome data under a unified held-out evaluation framework. For count prediction, we compare PLN and GLMNet(Poisson) on 20 datasets spanning 32 to 18,270 samples and 24 to 257 taxa, using held-out Poisson deviance under leave-one-taxon-out prediction with 3-fold sample cross-validation rather than synthetic or in-sample criteria. For network inference, we compare PLNNetwork and GLMNet(Poisson) neighborhood selection on five publicly available datasets with experimentally validated microbial interaction truth. PLN outperforms GLMNet(Poisson) on most count-prediction datasets, with gains up to 38 percent. The primary predictor of the winner is the sample-to-taxon ratio, with mean absolute correlation as the strongest secondary signal and overdispersion as an additional predictor. PLNNetwork performs best on broad undirected interaction benchmarks, whereas GLMNet(Poisson) is better aligned with local or directional effects. Taken together, these results provide guidance for choosing between latent multivariate count models and penalized Poisson regression in biological count prediction and interaction recovery.

微生物组泊松模型统计推断机器学习

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。