AI助益短期提分,却让人心变懒、更易放弃,长远不利学习。
AI Assistance Reduces Persistence and Hurts Independent Performance

- AI即时给答案,削弱人自主应对挑战的意愿。
- 仅10分钟使用就显著降低独立完成任务能力。
- 适合关注长期学习效果的教育与AI设计者阅读。
在一系列随机对照实验(N = 1,222)中,我们发现人工智能辅助带来两个关键后果:降低坚持性并损害无协助时的表现。在数学推理和阅读理解等任务中,尽管使用AI能短期提升表现,但人们在无AI时表现更差且更易放弃。这些影响在仅约10分钟的互动后即出现。持久性是技能习得的基础,也是长期学习最强预测因素之一。我们认为,这是因为AI让人习惯即时获得答案,剥夺了克服困难的锻炼机会。研究提示,应推动AI模型在完成任务的同时,更重视培养长期能力。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
People often optimize for long-term goals in collaboration: A mentor or companion doesn't just answer questions, but also scaffolds learning, tracks progress, and prioritizes the other person's growth over immediate results. In contrast, current AI systems are fundamentally short-sighted collaborators - optimized for providing instant and complete responses, without ever saying no (unless for safety reasons). What are the consequences of this dynamic? Here, through a series of randomized controlled trials on human-AI interactions (N = 1,222), we provide causal evidence for two key consequences of AI assistance: reduced persistence and impairment of unassisted performance. Across a variety of tasks, including mathematical reasoning and reading comprehension, we find that although AI assistance improves performance in the short-term, people perform significantly worse without AI and are more likely to give up. Notably, these effects emerge after only brief interactions with AI (approximately 10 minutes). These findings are particularly concerning because persistence is foundational to skill acquisition and is one of the strongest predictors of long-term learning. We posit that persistence is reduced because AI conditions people to expect immediate answers, thereby denying them the experience of working through challenges on their own. These results suggest the need for AI model development to prioritize scaffolding long-term competence alongside immediate task completion.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。