揭穿AI领域虚假问责陷阱,直面其背后的权力与财富结构
Reckoning with the Political Economy of AI: Avoiding Decoys in Pursuit of Accountability
- 识别五类看似批判实则强化科技霸权的'伪问责'话语
- 指出这些话语掩盖了AI项目背后的权力与资本运作机制
- 适合关注AI治理、技术政治经济学的学者与政策制定者
AI项目是一项构建世界的过程,资助与开发AI系统的人既依赖也维系着权力与财富网络。随着他们扩大资源获取并塑造我们的社会技术条件,一系列‘伪问责’话语诱导学者、批评者、政策制定者、记者和公众共同构建有利于产业的未来。这些话语虽看似提出质疑,实则掩盖了AI项目所催生的新兴政治经济格局,并强化了其核心的汲取与剥削机制。本文结合传播学、科技研究与经济社会学文献,剖析AI项目的建构逻辑,揭示五类实际助益产业而非推动变革的‘伪问责’陷阱。文章主张,实现真正公平与问责的关键在于:一是识别伪问责作为分心策略的时机与方式;二是直接面对AI项目背后的物质性政治经济现实。唯有如此,才能关注使‘AI’成为可能的权力网络,激发对更公正技术交织世界的全新构想。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
The Project of AI is a world-building endeavor, wherein those who fund and develop AI systems both operate through and seek to sustain networks of power and wealth. As they expand their access to resources and configure our sociotechnical conditions, they benefit from the ways in which a suite of decoys animate scholars, critics, policymakers, journalists, and the public into co-constructing industry-empowering AI futures. Regardless of who constructs or nurtures them, these decoys often create the illusion of accountability while both masking the emerging political economies that the Project of AI has set into motion, and also contributing to the network-making power that is at the heart of the Project's extraction and exploitation. Drawing on literature at the intersection of communication, science and technology studies, and economic sociology, we examine how the Project of AI is constructed. We then explore five decoys that seemingly critique - but in actuality co-constitute - AI's emergent power relations and material political economy. We argue that advancing meaningful fairness or accountability in AI requires: 1) recognizing when and how decoys serve as a distraction, and 2) grappling directly with the material political economy of the Project of AI. Doing so will enable us to attend to the networks of power that make 'AI' possible, spurring new visions for how to realize a more just technologically entangled world.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。