用预测必要性测试取代系数大小,更可靠地发现非线性时间序列中的因果关系
Beyond Coefficients: Forecast-Necessity Testing for Interpretable Causal Discovery in Nonlinear Time-Series Models

- 通过系统性删除边并比较预测效果,检验因果关系是否真正必要
- 实证显示相似因果得分的变量预测必要性差异巨大,受冗余与时序特性影响
- 适合高风险领域中解释非线性模型因果输出的研究者和应用者
非线性机器学习模型在时间序列因果发现中日益广泛应用,但其输出解释仍不清晰。现有方法常将正则化神经自回归模型的因果得分视为回归系数的类比,导致对统计显著性的误判。本文主张,在非线性时间序列模型中,因果相关性应通过预测必要性而非系数大小来评估,并提出一种可解释的评估框架。该框架基于系统性边删减与预测对比,检验候选因果关系是否对准确预测不可或缺。以神经加性向量自回归(Neural Additive Vector Autoregression)为例,我们在包含139个国家民主指标的面板数据上开展实证研究。结果表明,具有相似因果得分的变量在预测必要性上存在显著差异,这源于冗余、时序持续性及制度特异性效应。研究证明,预测必要性测试能提升实际人工智能系统中因果推理的可靠性,并为高风险领域中解释非线性时间序列模型提供实践指导。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Nonlinear machine-learning models are increasingly used to discover causal relationships in time-series data, yet the interpretation of their outputs remains poorly understood. In particular, causal scores produced by regularized neural autoregressive models are often treated as analogues of regression coefficients, leading to misleading claims of statistical significance. In this paper, we argue that causal relevance in nonlinear time-series models should be evaluated through forecast necessity rather than coefficient magnitude, and we present a practical evaluation procedure for doing so. We present an interpretable evaluation framework based on systematic edge ablation and forecast comparison, which tests whether a candidate causal relationship is required for accurate prediction. Using Neural Additive Vector Autoregression as a case study model, we apply this framework to a real-world case study of democratic development, modeled as a multivariate time series of panel data - democracy indicators across 139 countries. We show that relationships with similar causal scores can differ dramatically in their predictive necessity due to redundancy, temporal persistence, and regime-specific effects. Our results demonstrate how forecast-necessity testing supports more reliable causal reasoning in applied AI systems and provides practical guidance for interpreting nonlinear time-series models in high-stakes domains.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。