提出可量化课堂对话的多模态分析框架,提升研究可信度与可扩展性。
Audio Video Verbal Analysis (AVVA) for Capturing Classroom Dialogues
- 基于原文转录与关键互动模式,融合定性与定量分析
- 通过四准则评估稳定性的方法识别变量间不同尺度关系
- 适合教育数据研究者构建高可信、可复现的课堂对话分析流程
课堂话语分析因音视频多模态数据的普及而发展,亟需兼顾解释深度与计算可扩展性的方法。本研究提出音频-视频-言语分析(AVVA)框架,源自言语分析法,将定性解读与量化建模结合。不同于全多模态学习分析方法,AVVA聚焦原文转录与核心交互模态。框架在十步方法中嵌入三角验证,增强有效性与分析严谨性。通过综合验证方案解决时序观察研究中的三大挑战:低频变量的Phi上限问题(通过基率过滤)、估计不确定性(通过自助法置信区间)以及可变时间单元问题(观测窗口大小影响关联性)。采用四准则稳定性评估(符号一致性、置信区间重叠、零值排除、幅度稳定)对变量对进行分类,识别出跨时间粒度的稳定结构:粒度不变型、尺度特定型或多重尺度型等。该框架应用于23小时课堂录音,验证了其实际可行性与生成有意义洞察的潜力。因此,该方法为将丰富的课堂话语转化为可分析数据集提供了可扩展路径。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Background: The classroom discourse analysis has been transformed by the growing use of audio-video multimodal data, which demands analytical methods that balance interpretive depth with computational scalability. Methods: This study introduces the Audio Video Verbal Analysis (AVVA) framework, adapted from the Verbal Analysis method to integrate qualitative interpretation with quantitative modelling. Unlike fully multimodal learning analytics approaches, AVVA focuses on verbatim transcripts with essential interactional modalities. Findings: The framework embeds triangulation as a core design strategy across ten methodological steps, strengthening validity and analytical rigour. A comprehensive validation scheme addresses fundamental challenges in temporal observational research: Phi Ceiling for low-frequency variables (via Base Rate Filtering), estimation uncertainty (via bootstrap confidence intervals), and the Modifiable Temporal Unit Problem, where measured associations depend on observational window size. Four-criterion stability assessment (sign consistency, confidence interval overlap, zero exclusion, magnitude stability) classifies variable pairs into interpretable patterns: grain-invariant, scale-specific, or multi-scale, etc. structures across temporal grain sizes. Its application to 23 hours of classroom recordings illustrates its practical viability and its potential to yield meaningful insights. Contribution: The framework thus provides a scalable pathway for transforming rich classroom discourse into analysable datasets.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。