arXiv:2604.25774cs.CLcs.AI2026-04中稿 · the Third Workshop…

对比传统与大模型方法,发现大模型更准但慢,适合高精度营养估算。

CGU-ILALab at FoodBench-QA 2026: Comparing Traditional and LLM-based Approaches for Recipe Nutrient Estimation

  • 用词频+回归、深度编码器、大模型三类方法比较营养估算效果
  • 大模型在所有营养类别中准确率最高,但推理延迟显著增加
  • 适合对精度要求高、不介意延迟的饮食监测系统部署

从非结构化食谱文本中准确估算营养成分是饮食监测中的重要但具挑战性的问题,主要因食材术语模糊和数量表达多样。我们系统评估了涵盖多种表征能力的模型:从词频匹配方法(TF-IDF结合岭回归),到深度语义编码器(DeBERTa-v3),再到生成式推理的大语言模型(LLMs)。在欧盟1169/2011法规定义的严格容差标准下,实验结果揭示了预测精度与计算效率之间的明显权衡。TF-IDF基线模型实现中等估算性能且近乎瞬时推理;而DeBERTa-v3在任务特定数据稀缺时表现不佳。相反,少样本大模型推理(如Gemini 2.5 Flash)及混合优化流程(TF-IDF结合Gemini 2.5 Flash)在所有营养类别中均达到最高验证准确率。这些提升可能源于大模型利用预训练世界知识解决术语歧义和标准化非标准单位的能力,这是纯词法方法难以实现的。然而,这种优势伴随显著更高的推理延迟,凸显了实时效率与营养精度之间的实际部署权衡。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Accurate nutrient estimation from unstructured recipe text is an important yet challenging problem in dietary monitoring, due to ambiguous ingredient terminology and highly variable quantity expressions. We systematically evaluate models spanning a wide range of representational capacity, from lexical matching methods (TF-IDF with Ridge Regression), to deep semantic encoders (DeBERTa-v3), to generative reasoning with large language models (LLMs). Under the strict tolerance criteria defined by EU Regulation 1169/2011, our empirical results reveal a clear trade-off between predictive accuracy and computational efficiency. The TF-IDF baseline achieves moderate nutrient estimation performance with near-instantaneous inference, whereas the DeBERTa-v3 encoder performs poorly under task-specific data scarcity. In contrast, few-shot LLM inference (e.g., Gemini 2.5 Flash) and a hybrid LLM refinement pipeline (TF-IDF combined with Gemini 2.5 Flash) deliver the highest validation accuracy across all nutrient categories. These improvements likely arise from the ability of LLMs to leverage pre-trained world knowledge to resolve ambiguous terminology and normalize non-standard units, which remain difficult for purely lexical approaches. However, these gains come at the cost of substantially higher inference latency, highlighting a practical deployment trade-off between real-time efficiency and nutritional precision in dietary monitoring systems.

营养估算大模型应用食谱分析

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。