arXiv:2604.26521cs.AIcs.CV2026-04AAAI

神经符号系统中,符号接地不能自动带来推理泛化,需显式学习。

Grounding vs. Compositionality: On the Non-Complementarity of Reasoning in Neuro-Symbolic Systems

论文配图:Grounding vs. Compositionality: On the Non-Complementarity of Reasoning in Neuro-Symbolic Systems
图 1 · 摘自论文原文
  • 提出可微的迭代逻辑张量网络,支持多步推理
  • 仅训练接地任务时零样本准确率不足20%
  • 联合训练接地与推理后,所有任务零样本准确率超80%

组合泛化仍是现代神经网络的根本弱点,限制其在需要分布外推理领域中的鲁棒性与应用。神经符号人工智能中一个核心但未经验证的假设是:符号接地成功后,组合推理将自然涌现。本文首次通过系统实证分析挑战该假设,分离接地与推理的贡献。为此,我们引入可微的迭代逻辑张量网络(iLTN),用于多步演绎。基于形式化的泛化分类——探测新实体、未见关系及复杂规则组合——我们发现,仅以接地目标训练的模型无法泛化。相反,联合训练感知接地与多步推理的完整iLTN,在所有任务上均实现高零样本准确率。研究结果明确表明,符号接地虽必要,但不足以实现泛化,推理并非涌现能力,而是需显式学习的独立能力。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Compositional generalization remains a foundational weakness of modern neural networks, limiting their robustness and applicability in domains requiring out-of-distribution reasoning. A central, yet unverified, assumption in neuro-symbolic AI is that compositional reasoning will emerge as a byproduct of successful symbol grounding. This work presents the first systematic empirical analysis to challenge this assumption by disentangling the contributions of grounding and reasoning. To operationalize this investigation, we introduce the Iterative Logic Tensor Network ($i$LTN), a fully differentiable architecture designed for multi-step deduction. Using a formal taxonomy of generalization -- probing for novel entities, unseen relations, and complex rule compositions -- we demonstrate that a model trained solely on a grounding objective fails to generalize. In contrast, our full $i$LTN, trained jointly on perceptual grounding and multi-step reasoning, achieves high zero-shot accuracy across all tasks. Our findings provide conclusive evidence that symbol grounding, while necessary, is insufficient for generalization, establishing that reasoning is not an emergent property but a distinct capability that requires an explicit learning objective.

神经符号组合泛化可微逻辑

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。