arXiv:2605.14480cs.CL2026-05

明代多语词典用汉字音近转写异族语言,揭示古代跨语言语音记录的系统性。

Cross-Linguistic Transcription and Phonological Representation in the Huìtóngguǎnxì Huáyíyìyǔ

  • 将明代多语词典视为统一音转系统,分析汉字表音规则。
  • 主转写符和补充转写符分别对应符合与不符合汉语音节结构的发音。
  • 为无文字语言的古音研究提供关键证据,适合语言史与文献学研究者。

本研究探讨明代政府编纂的《会通管系华夷译语》(HHY)中多语词典的音转原则。该词典并非孤立语言材料的集合,而是一个以汉字记录非汉语口语的连贯多语音转体系。通过数字化处理并对照汉语语音范畴,对八个语言部分的主转写(MT)与补充转写(ST)进行分析。结果显示,主转写基本符合明代汉语音节结构,而补充转写则主要标记汉语音韵难以容纳的语音特征。分析表明,汉字在转写外族语言时使用更具灵活性,反映的是相对系统的语音近似方法,而非简单套用汉语音系。因此,HHY应被视为一个内在结构化的音转系统,而非单纯词典汇编。该研究证明,历史音转系统可为缺乏书面记录的亚洲语言提供重要的历史音韵证据。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Purpose: This study investigates the transcription principles underlying Huìtóngguǎnxì Huáyíyìyǔ (HHY), a series of multilingual glossaries compiled by the Ming government between the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries for interpreter training. The study treats HHY not as a collection of isolated language materials, but as a coherent multilingual transcription system representing spoken forms of non-Chinese languages through Chinese characters. Methods: A substantial portion of HHY was digitized and aligned with Chinese phonological categories. Previous reconstructions of individual language sections were critically reviewed and integrated into a unified comparative database. The analysis focuses on cross-linguistic regularities in Main Transcription (MT) and Supplementary Transcription (ST) across eight language sections. Results: MT generally represents sounds compatible with the Chinese syllable structure of the period, whereas ST mainly encodes phonetic features less compatible with Chinese phonology. The analysis further shows that Chinese phonological categories were used more flexibly in foreign-language transcription than previously assumed. HHY therefore functioned as a relatively systematic method of phonetic approximation rather than a direct projection of Chinese phonology onto non-Chinese languages. Conclusion: HHY can be analyzed as an internally structured transcription system rather than merely as a collection of glossaries. More broadly, the study demonstrates that historical transcription systems can provide valuable evidence for historical phonology, particularly for under-documented Asian languages with limited historical records.

音转系统历史音韵多语词典汉语史

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。