arXiv:2605.30195cond-mat.mtrl-scics.AI2026-05

拆解分子MPNN的三类消息操作,发现信息构建比更新复杂度更影响性能。

What drives performance in molecular MPNNs? An operator-level factorial benchmark

  • 将MPNN分解为初始化、融合、更新三类操作,系统测试84种组合。
  • 消息构建方式差异导致性能波动,而更新操作影响不显著。
  • 拼接融合优于哈达玛门控,适合区分化学异构原子和防过平滑。

消息传递神经网络(MPNN)广泛用于分子性质预测,但其整体架构使特定消息传递操作的影响难以识别。本文提出一个操作级因子实验设计,将二维分子MPNN分解为消息种子初始化、节点-边融合、节点更新三类操作家族。在统一实验设置下,对10个MoleculeNet数据集进行测试,共评估84种配置。结果表明,性能差异主要源于消息构建而非更新复杂度:消息种子初始化对回归与分类均有显著家族效应;节点-边融合在回归任务中具显著家族效应,拼接混合方式表现更优;更新家族对两类任务均无统计显著影响。对喹那唑酮分子的表征探测显示,拼接融合能更好区分化学上不同的杂原子,并有效抵抗过平滑。针对分类与回归分别选取的代表性配置,在10个数据集中有8个达到或超过现有分子图神经网络基线性能。通过代表性融合与更新算子的机制分析,本文提供实证设计指导,将模型设计从整体架构搜索转为对化学信息进入消息传递流程的精准定位。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Message-passing neural networks (MPNNs) are widely used for molecular property prediction, but their deployment as monolithic architectures makes it difficult to identify how specific message-passing operators affect performance. We present an operator-level factorial benchmark that decomposes 2D molecular MPNNs into the three families of message-seed initialization, node-edge fusion, and node update operators. The resulting 84 configurations are benchmarked on ten MoleculeNet datasets under a shared experimental setup and statistical analysis protocol. Across this controlled design, performance variation is associated primarily with message construction rather than update complexity. Message-seed initialization shows significant family-level effects for both regression and classification, node-edge fusion shows a significant family-level effect for regression with descriptive advantages for concatenation-based mixing, and the update family shows no statistically supported effect for either endpoint family. A representation probe into the Quinethazone molecule further demonstrates that concatenation-based mixing can better differentiate chemically distinct heteroatoms and withstand oversmoothing than Hadamard gating. Representative configurations selected separately for classification and regression recover competitive performance relative to established molecular graph neural network (GNN) baselines, ranking numerically best on eight of ten benchmark datasets. These empirical results are interpreted through concise mechanistic analyses of representative node-edge fusion and update operators. Our findings provide empirical design heuristics for molecular MPNNs by turning model design from a search over monolithic architectures into a targeted assessment of where and how chemical information enters the message-passing pipeline.

分子建模图神经网络消息传递可解释性

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。