扩散模型更易记住常见片段,而非罕见样本。
Diffusion Models Preferentially Memorize Prototypical Examples or: Why Does My Diffusion Model Love Slop?

- 基于随机层级模型生成数据,发现模型优先记忆常见子串。
- 即使数据点全唯一,仍会优先记忆高频模式,去重无效。
- 训练中途停止会导致生成结果趋同平庸,产生‘低质冗余’
生成模型存在持久性缺陷:倾向于记忆训练数据,带来法律风险并削弱创作多样性。理解哪些样本被完整或部分记忆,以及在何种条件下发生,仍是重要开放问题。本文回答‘异常或稀有样本是否最先被记忆?’,答案是否定的。我们在随机层级模型(RHM)生成的字符串上训练扩散模型,发现由常见子串构成的样本会被优先记忆。即使训练数据完全唯一,这一现象依然成立,表明仅在样本层面去重无法提供有效隐私保护。相应地,我们预测并观察到,在长尾分布数据集上记忆延迟出现;当高层生成规则引入长尾时,该效应进一步放大。这说明数据多样性,尤其是在抽象层次上的多样性,对延缓记忆至关重要。最后,我们发现一个中间阶段:模型先学习常见子串,并在生成中过度复制。若在此阶段停止训练,模型将表现出回归均值的平庸特性,常被称为‘slop’。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Generative models have a persistent limitation: their tendency to memorize training data can create legal liabilities and erode creative diversity. Understanding which samples are memorized in whole or in part, and under what conditions, therefore remains an important open problem. Here we answer the question "Are atypical or rare samples memorized first?" in the negative. We train diffusion models on strings generated according to the production rules of the Random Hierarchy Model (RHM), and find that samples composed of common substrings are preferentially memorized. This holds true even if the training data consists of entirely unique samples, indicating that deduplication at the data point level does not provide a meaningful privacy guarantee. Correspondingly we predict, then observe, delayed memorization for fat-tailed datasets (i.e., those with more atypical samples). This effect is amplified when fat-tails are introduced into high-level production rules. These together suggest that dataset diversity, particularly at higher levels of abstraction, plays an important role in staving off memorization. Finally, we identify an intermediate regime of partial memorization in which common substrings are learned first and subsequently overproduced during generation. If training is stopped in this regime, models will exhibit the reversion-to-the-mean blandness often derided as "slop".
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。