arXiv:2606.06646cs.CLcs.AI2026-06中稿 · publication in the…

多智能体系统自动构建符合CAF框架的复杂论证结构

CAF-Gen: A Multi-Agent System for Enriching Argumentation Structures

论文配图:CAF-Gen: A Multi-Agent System for Enriching Argumentation Structures
图 1 · 摘自论文原文
  • 采用创作者-评审者迭代机制生成论证结构
  • 生成模型与原始标注高度一致,结构更丰富
  • 适合需要严谨论证建模的研究者使用

从自然文本中形式化复杂推理是计算语言学的核心挑战,要求系统不仅理解关键词,还需把握上下文与深层推理。现有论点挖掘(AM)技术仅能识别基本论点和前提,难以捕捉卡内迪斯论证框架(CAF)所需的丰富结构信息,如前提类型、证明标准和论证模式。为此,我们提出CAF-Gen,一种自动化多智能体框架,可将浅层论证结构扩展为符合CAF规范的论证模型。通过迭代的创作者-评审者流程,创作者输出由批判性代理验证,确保结构完整性。该多智能体协作有效缓解了单次生成模型常见的结构不稳定性。实验表明,迭代反馈环提升了数据质量,与原始标注高度对齐,且生成了更丰富的结构模型。结果证明,多智能体系统能克服单次生成的局限,为形式化论证的自动化建模提供稳健方法。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Formalizing complex reasoning from natural text is one of the central challenges in computational linguistics. It requires systems to understand not just keywords but also the context and complex reasoning embedded in a text. Current Argument Mining (AM) techniques identify basic claims and premises, yet they often struggle to capture the richer structural information required by advanced schemas such as the Carneades Argumentation Framework (CAF), which incorporates features such as premise types, proof standards, and argument schemes. We address this limitation by introducing CAF-Gen, an automated multi-agent framework designed to enrich shallow argument structures into CAF-compliant argument models. By employing an iterative Creator-Reviewer pipeline, a creator agent's output is validated by a critical agent to ensure structural integrity. This multi-agent collaboration is crucial for mitigating the structural instability typical of single-pass generative models. Our experiments demonstrate that the iterative feedback loop improves the quality of the resulting data and achieves strong alignment with the original annotations, while producing structurally richer models. Our findings show that the multi-agent system can overcome the limitations of single-pass generation, providing a robust methodology for the automated modeling of formal argumentation.

论证挖掘多智能体形式化推理

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。