AI讲故事时回避性别,反而让女性动物角色几乎消失。
Neutrality Bites: Gender Representation in AI-Generated Animal Stories

- 用拟人动物故事测试大模型的性别分配倾向。
- 40.6%故事出现男性动物,女性仅2.2%,中性代词占38.2%。
- 盲目追求中立反致女性角色被抹除,需新策略平衡想象空间。
AI生成故事中的性别偏见问题已广受关注。为检验干预措施是否真正公平,我们研究大语言模型(LLMs)在高度模糊且易复制人类刻板印象的拟人动物故事中如何处理性别指派。我们向六款主流LLM提出任务,完成七种未指定性别的拟人动物角色的英文故事,涵盖四种叙事场景和多种模型温度。共生成23,800篇故事,发现模型普遍回避性别指派(平均19%),或使用中性代词如“it”/“its”(平均38.2%)。但一旦赋性别,存在显著男性偏向:女性角色仅占2.2%,而男性角色达40.6%。结果表明,过度追求中立反而导致边缘群体身份被消解。建议探索超越中立的策略,更均衡地分配虚构主体的社会可能性。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Gender bias in AI-generated stories is a well-documented problem. While much attention has been paid to reducing or mitigating this bias, it is not always clear whether interventions produce genuinely fairer results. To investigate this issue, we examine how large language models (LLMs) handle gender assignment in a narrative context that is popular, highly ambiguous, and also known to closely reproduce human stereotypes: stories about talking animals. We prompt six leading LLMs to complete an English-language story about seven different anthropomorphic animal characters whose gender is unstated. We additionally iterate with four different narrative settings and a range of model temperatures. Across the 23.8K stories, we find that models frequently avoid gendering the animal character in the story (19% on average) or use gender-neutral language like "it" or "its" (38.2% on average). However, when gender is assigned, there is a significant masculine bias. Feminine animal characters are virtually absent, present in just 2.2% of stories vs. 40.6% that feature masculine characters. Our findings point to a broader argument: neutrality bites. In other words, models that prioritize neutrality to address social bias may actually contribute to the erasure of marginalized perspectives and identities. We suggest that alternative strategies beyond neutrality need to be pursued, such as ones that more equally distribute social possibilities across imagined subjects.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。