评测大模型能否基于真实时间限制做出有效推理预测
WorldReasoner: Evaluating Whether Language Model Agents Forecast Events with Valid Reasoning

- 构建时间约束下的事件预测评估框架,只允许使用预测时已知信息
- 发现时间受限检索显著提升预测准确率,因果图帮助识别关键事件
- 模型虽能引用相关证据,但难以将证据转化为合理概率判断
现实世界事件预测需要语言模型在信息不全、时间有限的情况下进行推理。但仅靠最终答案正确性无法判断模型是否真正具备预测能力——模型可能因记忆训练数据、编造证据或虚构因果故事而偶然正确。我们提出WorldReasoner,一个评估时间有效性事件预测的框架。每个任务提供已解决的预测问题、模拟预测日期及该日期前可获取的证据;任务结束后,框架从三个维度评分:结果准确性、引用证据质量、以及事后回溯构建的因果图推理质量。该基准通过智能体构建流程生成,涵盖14,141篇文献,构建出345个已解决任务,覆盖8,087个事件的因果图。在六种控制条件下,时间有效检索是提升结果准确性的最强因素;因果图构建有助于识别关键事件;正确的图引导预测更依赖关键事件与相关来源,但模型仍难以将可信证据转化为校准的概率。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Forecasting real-world events requires language-model agents to reason under uncertainty from incomplete, time-bounded information. Yet evaluating whether agents genuinely forecast requires more than final-answer accuracy: a model may be correct by recalling memorized training facts, citing fabricated evidence, or producing an unsupported causal story. We present WorldReasoner, an evaluation framework for temporally valid event forecasting. Each task gives an agent a resolved forecasting question, a simulated forecast date, and access only to evidence available before that date; after resolution, the framework scores the submitted probability, cited evidence, and optional causal event graph. WorldReasoner reports three complementary axes: outcome quality against resolved answers, evidence quality over cited sources, and reasoning quality against post-resolution hindsight graphs. The benchmark is built by an agentic construction pipeline that generates forecasting questions, collects time-stamped evidence, and builds hindsight reference graphs at scale, yielding 345 resolved tasks derived from 14,141 articles with graphs covering 8,087 extracted events. Across six controlled agent settings, temporally valid retrieval is the strongest driver of outcome accuracy; causal graph construction improves key-event recovery; and correct graph-enabled forecasts are more strongly grounded in key events and relevant sources, yet agents still struggle to convert grounded evidence into calibrated probabilities.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。