用用户反馈预测临床大模型回答被拒风险,提升系统实用性。
Deployment-Centered Evaluation: Predicting Query-Level Rejection Risk in a Clinical LLM System

- 基于查询内容和部署上下文预判回答被拒概率。
- 4.5个月数据验证,预测准确率AUROC达0.719。
- 适合关注临床LLM落地效果的开发者与医疗系统设计者。
大型语言模型(LLMs)正日益融入临床系统,但传统静态评测侧重正确性、聚合整体表现且需密集标注,难以反映真实使用情况。本文在一家医学中心的电子病历系统中开展以部署为中心的评估,利用稀疏但贴近真实场景的用户反馈,训练一个预响应分类器,根据查询内容和生成前的部署上下文(如医生类型、科室、使用的语言模型)预测未来交互被拒绝的风险。在为期4.5个月的前瞻性分析中,模型获得AUROC 0.719。进一步估算显示,该预测可用于触发防护机制或主动回避。核心发现是:结合部署上下文比仅依赖查询内容能更准确预测用户拒绝行为。本研究证明了利用部署上下文预测拒绝风险的可行性,为构建针对性防护机制提供了可能。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly integrated into clinical systems, making it essential to evaluate the real-world utility of these systems. However, static benchmarks tend to measure correctness rather than user acceptance, aggregate performance across queries, and require densely annotated datasets -- leading to major blind spots for evaluating clinical systems. In this work, we perform a deployment-centered evaluation of an LLM system embedded within electronic health records at an academic medical center, where user feedback is sparse but closely reflects the deployment conditions. Specifically, we train a pre-response classifier that estimates the risk that a future interaction will result in the user rejecting the LLM response, based on query content and deployment-specific context available before generation. We conduct a prospective analysis of our model over 4.5 months of user feedback, finding that our prediction model achieves an AUROC of 0.719. Further, we estimate the benefit of such predictions in two downstream use cases (guardrail triggering and abstention). Our key conceptual insight is that making use of deployment-specific context (i.e., the provider type, department name, language model used for response), as opposed to only query content, improves the ability to predict whether the user will reject the system output. Altogether, our empirical case study demonstrates the feasibility of predicting user rejection using deployment-specific context, opening the door to targeted guardrails.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。