arXiv:2606.15998cs.IRcs.AI2026-06被引 1

实体相关性不等于检索信号,需关注实体是否真实区分相关与无关文档。

Entity Labels Are Not Entity Signals: A Framework for Observable Relevance in Document Re-Ranking

论文配图:Entity Labels Are Not Entity Signals: A Framework for Observable Relevance in Document Re-Ranking
图 1 · 摘自论文原文
  • 区分概念相关性(CER)与可观测相关性(OER),强调实体出现是否具区分力。
  • CER与OER几乎无关(κ≈0),用CER训练会误选弱判别实体。
  • 对齐监督信号到OER,可提升非相关文档剔除率10倍、开放世界MAP达0.051提升。

实体感知文档检索依赖查询关联实体作为排序信号,假设语义相关实体即为有效信号。本文指出该假设不成立:实体链接是不完美的推测,一个主题核心的实体若在相关与无关文档中均被频繁链接,则无区分能力。本文提出概念实体相关性(CER)与可观测实体相关性(OER)的区分:前者指实体与查询的主题相关性,后者指其在文档集合中能否有效区分相关与非相关文档。在四个数据集上,基于人类标注的CER与OER仅接近随机一致(κ≈0),而不同OER定义间一致性较高(κ≈0.5),表明CER为系统性偏差。以CER为监督信号时,仅能剔除不足4%的非相关文档;而转向以OER为监督,非相关文档剔除能力最高提升10倍,开放世界MAP相比BM25提升0.051。研究推动实体检索从概念相关转向可观测相关。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Entity-aware document retrieval uses query-associated entities as ranking signals, assuming that semantically relevant entities are also useful retrieval signals. We show this assumption is insufficient- and explain why. Unlike terms, which are ground-truth observations, entity links are hypotheses produced by an imperfect linker: an entity can be topically central yet provide no discriminative signal if the linker fires indiscriminately across relevant and non-relevant documents. We formalize this as a distinction between Conceptual Entity Relevance (CER)- whether an entity is topically related to a query- and Observable Entity Relevance (OER)- whether its observed presence in a collection discriminates relevant from non-relevant documents. Across four collections and annotation sources including human entity judgments, CER and OER exhibit near-chance agreement ($κ\approx 0$), while OER operationalizations agree substantially ($κ\approx 0.5$), confirming CER as the systematic outlier. CER-based supervision selects topically plausible but weakly discriminative entities, pruning fewer than 4% of non-relevant documents on some collections. Aligning supervision with OER improves non-relevant pruning by up to 10x and open-world MAP by 0.051 over BM25. Our findings motivate a shift from conceptual to observable notions of entity relevance in entity-aware retrieval.

信息检索实体相关性排序优化

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。