系统评估四种分布偏移对传感器动作识别的影响,揭示现有泛化方法效果有限。
Assessing Distribution Shift in Human Activity Recognition for Domain Generalization

- 构建统一的HAR分布偏移基准,涵盖设备、位置、采样率和用户行为四类变化
- 28种域泛化方法在该基准上表现仅略优于经验风险最小化基线
- 首次系统分析特定分布偏移对动作识别泛化能力的影响,适合研究域泛化与智能穿戴
尽管人体动作识别(HAR)领域持续吸引研究关注并取得重要进展,但一些关键挑战仍存在。构建在真实场景中表现良好的HAR模型所面临的主要难题之一是设备与传感器异质性以及应用场景中的上下文变化带来的数据多样性。虽然文献已广泛承认HAR中的数据多样性,但对各类分布偏移对HAR模型的影响及其引发的域泛化问题的理解仍不充分。为此,本文系统评估了四种分布偏移类型:设备类型、传感器位置、采样率和用户行为差异。通过量化其影响,我们发现多样性偏移主导了所有类型偏移,表明不同域间存在独特且非共享特征。随后,我们引入一个统一的基于HAR的分布偏移基准,并对多达28种域泛化方法进行了全面评估。分析显示,当前域泛化算法在实现模型泛化能力方面存在明显局限,仅略优于经验风险最小化基线。本工作是首个针对传感器驱动的HAR中特定分布偏移的域泛化与适应问题的系统性探索,提供了开源基准平台与数据集,以推动后续研究。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
While the field of Human Activity Recognition (HAR) continues to draw interest from researchers and advance in important ways, some key challenges remain. One of the most difficult aspects of building HAR models that show good performance in real-world settings is dealing with data diversity from device and sensor heterogeneity, and contextual changes that are intrinsic to real-world applications. While data diversity in HAR has been well-acknowledged in the literature, there remains a gap in understanding the effect of various types of distribution shifts on HAR models and the domain generalization problem that arises. Towards that end, this paper systematically evaluates 4 different types of distribution shifts, including variations in device type, sensor placement, sampling rate, and user behavior. Quantifying their effects, we illustrate that diversity shifts predominantly define all types of shifts, indicating the existence of unique features that are not shared across different domains. We then introduce a uniform HAR-based distribution shift benchmarks and conduct a comprehensive evaluation of up to 28 domain generalization methods. Our analysis exposes the limitations of current domain generalization algorithms in achieving model generalizability, marginally outperforming the empirical risk minimization baseline. This work represents the first systematic exploration of domain generalization and adaptation concerning specific distribution shifts in sensor-based HAR, offering an open-source benchmark platform and datasets to spur further research.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。