让编码代理自动复现科学机器学习论文的计算结论
Coding-agents can replicate scientific machine learning papers
- 将论文每个结论设为可追踪目标,生成可验证证据链
- 12次复现全部通过验证,158个目标均在报告中覆盖
- 适合希望自动化复现科研成果的研究者
科学机器学习论文通常包含计算性声明,例如相对均方误差低于5%,或95%预测可信区间覆盖测试数据。编码代理可仅凭论文材料被提示复现这些结论,但提示本身无法可靠保证进展或验证生成证据是否支持原论文主张。本文提出Paper-replication工作流,将每个选定论文结论作为带有记录证据的目标,并将其实现为编码代理的一项技能。该流程要求代理记录目标、重建论文方法、运行计算实验、关联输出溯源与原文结论对比,标记证据在复现报告中的位置,并在完成前通过验证检查。我们在四篇科学机器学习论文上进行了十二次独立复现评估。所有十二个工作空间均通过完成门禁,158个记录目标全部在报告中得到覆盖。即使在最终完成状态,重复运行仍存在目标划分差异、数值保真度不同、耗时差异、中间执行替换次数不一以及证据采纳规则各异等现象。Paper-replication使完成状态依赖于工作空间的证据和验证检查,而非代理的最终输出。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Scientific machine learning papers typically make computational claims, e.g., that the relative mean square error is less than 5% or that the 95% predictive credible interval covers the test data. A coding agent can be prompted to replicate those claims from paper materials alone, but the prompt does not by itself reliably preserve progress or check whether generated evidence supports the paper's claims. We introduce Paper-replication, a workflow that makes each selected paper claim a target with recorded evidence, and implement it as a coding-agent skill. The workflow makes the agent record those targets, reconstruct the paper's method, run computational experiments, link generated outputs to provenance and comparisons with the paper's claims, record where matched evidence appears in the replication report, and pass validation checks before completion. We evaluate Paper-replication on twelve independent runs across four scientific machine learning papers. All twelve workspaces pass the completion gate, and all 158 recorded targets are matched with report coverage. Even in this completed workspace state, repeated runs differ in how papers are divided into targets, in numerical fidelity to the source papers, in elapsed replication time, in the number of intermediate executions replaced before final evidence is accepted, and in the rules used to accept evidence. Paper-replication makes completion depend on workspace evidence and validation checks rather than on the agent's final message.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。