arXiv:2607.05477cs.MAcs.AI2026-07

对比三种协作策略,提升多智能体大模型的对话任务表现

Decision Protocols in Multi-Agent Large Language Model Conversations

论文配图:Decision Protocols in Multi-Agent Large Language Model Conversations
图 1 · 摘自论文原文
  • 设计MALLM框架,测试投票、共识、裁判三种决策协议
  • 共识策略在知识类任务上表现最优,投票和裁判更适合逻辑推理
  • 独立生成解法能提升决策质量,信息访问方式影响不大

提升大语言模型(LLM)的任务性能至关重要,但模型规模扩展面临收益递减和成本高昂的挑战。多智能体系统(MAS)通过将任务分配给专业化智能体,有望提升整体表现,代价是增加推理时间。决策协议是MAS的核心,决定智能体如何协同形成最终答案。本文提出多智能体大模型(MALLM)框架,系统评估投票、共识与裁判机制在多种任务上的表现,涵盖知识型数据集(MMLU、MMLU-Pro、GPQA)和逻辑型数据集(StrategyQA、MuSR、Math-lvl-5、SQuAD 2.0)。结果表明:共识协议在知识密集型任务中表现更优,而投票与裁判机制在逻辑任务中更有效;通过独立生成解法可提升决策质量,但决策过程中信息访问方式变化影响较小。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Improving the task performance of Large Language Models (LLMs) is essential, yet scaling these models faces significant challenges such as diminishing returns and high costs. Multi-Agent Systems (MAS) offer a promising solution by distributing tasks among specialized agents to improve the overall task performance. This can reduce training costs at the expense of increased test time due to the discussion and decision-making process. The decision protocol is a critical component of MAS because it specifies how multiple agents collaborate to create a final solution. This thesis introduces the Multi-Agent LLM (MALLM) framework, which implements and evaluates various decision protocols, namely voting, consensus, and judge decision mechanisms, to simulate multi-agent discussions for conversational task solving. Unlike previous work that used a single decision protocol or tested them on limited datasets, this study systematically examines their impact on a diverse set of tasks, ranging from knowledge-based datasets (MMLU, MMLU-Pro, GPQA) and logic-based datasets (StrategyQA, MuSR, Math-lvl-5, SQuAD 2.0). The results indicate that consensus protocols excel in knowledge-intensive domains while voting and judge protocols are more effective for logic-based tasks. Increasing response diversity through independent solution generation improves decision quality, while changes in information access during the decision process have minimal impact.

多智能体大模型决策机制

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。