让AI学会在模糊任务中通过互动理解用户真实意图
Interactive Task Alignment as a POMDP

- 将模糊任务转化为部分可观测马尔可夫决策过程,让模型推断隐藏任务
- 模型在不确定情况下仅22-32%正确对齐用户意图,远低于人类的48%
- 即使微调后仍难媲美人类,揭示当前AI交互能力短板
当前语言模型评测多基于明确指定的任务,但真实用户任务常模糊、探索性或不一致。助手需先理解用户真实意图才能执行。本文研究任务对齐问题:模型如何与用户达成意图一致。提出通用框架,将明确任务转为未明确交互,形式化为部分可观测马尔可夫决策过程(POMDP),要求模型从不断演化的用户意图中推断潜在任务。通过人工用户实验验证仿真器有效性。在购物、编程和专业工作场景中发现,尽管模型在任务明确后表现良好,但在任务对齐上仍存在明显不足:过早行动、交互低效、无法解决模糊请求。模型平均仅在22%-32%情况下正确恢复用户意图;而人类在相同场景下达48%,显著优于所有测试模型。结果显示,经监督微调和强化学习后,模型性能有所提升,但仍落后于人类通过交互化解不确定性的能力。总体表明,当前模型仍缺乏可靠代理所需的交互能力。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
Current benchmarks for language models primarily evaluate execution on fully specified tasks. However, real user tasks are often ambiguous. Users arrive with incomplete, exploratory, or even inconsistent goals, requiring the assistant to first determine the intended task before carrying it out. We study this problem as task alignment: the ability to align with a user on their intended task. We introduce a general framework for converting specified tasks into underspecified interactions, formalized as a POMDP in which the model must infer a latent task from partial and evolving user intent. We validate our user simulator post hoc with a human user study. Across shopping, coding, and professional work settings, we find that while models often perform well once the task is specified, models still struggle with task alignment: current models act prematurely, interact ineffectively, and fail to resolve ambiguous requests. Models on average recover the user's intended task only 22-32% of the time under ambiguity. In a human study in the same setting, humans reach 48%, outperforming all evaluated models. We show that post-training with supervised fine-tuning and reinforcement learning improves task alignment, but models still lag behind humans in resolving uncertainty through interaction. Together, our results suggest that current models still lack key interaction abilities required for reliable agency.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。