arXiv:2607.21547cs.AIcs.CL2026-07

人类参与自动化并非因AI不足,而是目标本身在互动中生成。

The Boundaries of Automation: A Theory of Persistent Human Participation

论文配图:The Boundaries of Automation: A Theory of Persistent Human Participation
图 1 · 摘自论文原文
  • 人类与AI共同构建目标,而非仅辅助执行
  • 目标未预先定义时,人类参与是产出必要条件
  • 适用于需动态生成目标的场景,如创意协作

AI快速发展推动自动化进程,普遍认为人类仅因当前系统能力不足而被保留。本文挑战这一假设,提出即使在高度智能的AI系统下,人类参与仍可能持续存在三类原因:技术互补性(人类提供AI无法替代的能力或视角)、规范性发展性(参与本身对人类能动性或学习有价值),以及最核心的涌现性——某些活动的目标并非预先设定,而是在人机互动中逐步形成。在此类活动中,人类参与不仅是提升效率的手段,更是目标产生的根本构成部分。因此,人机协同不是临时权宜之计,而是目标动态生成类活动的本质特征。该观点对自动化边界、未来AI系统的设计、评估与伦理具有重要意义。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

The rapid progress of AI has intensified the long-standing pursuit of automation: replacing human participation with algorithms wherever possible. Implicit in this pursuit is the assumption that humans remain in the loop only because current AI systems are not yet sufficiently capable. This paper challenges that assumption. Rather than asking how far automation can extend, we ask where its conceptual limits lie and argue that human participation may persist even with highly capable AI systems for three distinct reasons. Technical or complementarity grounds arise when humans contribute capabilities or perspectives unavailable to AI. Normative or developmental grounds arise when participation itself is valuable for human agency or learning. Most importantly, emergence grounds arise from target emergence: in some activities, the target is not fully specified in advance but instead emerges through the interaction itself. In these cases, human participation is not merely a means of improving execution but is constitutive of the target being produced. Human--AI co-construction, understood as the joint production of outcomes by humans and AI systems, is therefore not simply a temporary response to imperfect AI, but a persistent feature of activities whose objectives emerge through participation. This perspective has important implications for the limits of automation and for the design, evaluation, and ethics of future AI systems.

人机协作自动化边界目标涌现

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。