arXiv:2607.23942cs.AI2026-07综述被引 1

梳理智能体机制演进,揭示关键能力的融合与缺失。

From Cognitive Architectures to Language Agents: A Mechanism-Level Review of Lineage, Convergence, and Migration Gaps

  • 从控制语义重构十类认知架构与八类语言代理机制
  • 发现现代代理已实现自适应记忆、动态协作等核心能力
  • 提出可验证的机制组合框架,适合系统设计者参考

记忆、规划、反思和工具使用常被当作功能标签,掩盖了决定智能体实际运行的控制语义。本综述整合了十种历史认知架构、八类语言代理运行时家族及四十二个以机制为中心的现代系统。通过状态、控制、转移、持续性、失败、学习与资源治理重建每个机制,并独立标注证据关系(E1-E4)与迁移深度(D0-D4)。结果表明,现代代理已实现自适应记忆、失败恢复、动态团队选择、工作流搜索、技能归纳、资源调度和不确定性条件动作等能力,但多为独立收敛而非有据继承。现存主要机会在于机制间的耦合。最接近基线的筛选关闭了一个假设缺口:GraSP 已结合校准的多技能选择、类型化编译、验证、有界修复及重规划或 ReAct 回退。五个剩余机制包仍待解决:激活延迟与动作效用;类型化僵局与孤立子状态及解析编译;有界内容竞争与广播与准入学习;持久意图与重新考虑及实时方法权威;不确定性与资源分配、中断和终止。本文贡献了一个独特机制目录、可审计的证据-深度框架,以及可证伪的测试这些机制包作为可组合运行时不变量的议程。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

Memory, planning, reflection, and tool use are often compared as feature labels, obscuring the control semantics that determine how an agent actually runs. This review connects ten historical cognitive architectures, eight language-agent runtime families, and forty-two mechanism-focused modern systems. We reconstruct each mechanism through state, control, transition, persistence, failure, learning, and resource governance, then code evidence relation (E1-E4) separately from migration depth (D0-D4). The resulting landscape is uneven. Modern agents have operationalized substantial parts of adaptive memory, failure recovery, dynamic team selection, workflow search, skill induction, resource scheduling, and uncertainty-conditioned action, although often through independent convergence rather than documented inheritance. The strongest remaining opportunities lie in couplings among mechanisms. Closest-baseline screening closes one proposed gap: GraSP already combines calibrated multi-skill selection, typed compilation, verification, bounded repair, and replanning or ReAct fallback. Five residual bundles remain: activation with latency and action utility; typed impasse with isolated substates and resolution compilation; bounded content competition with broadcast and admission learning; persistent intention with reconsideration and live method authority; and uncertainty with resource allocation, interruption, and stopping. We contribute a distinctive-mechanism catalog, an auditable evidence-depth framework, and a falsifiable agenda for testing these bundles as composable runtime invariants.

认知架构智能体机制分析运行时

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。