对比欧美中AI监管,提出可审计的合规框架
Global AI Regulations for FAIR and Ethics in High-Risk Use Cases: A Comparative Review
- 构建三地监管对比矩阵,覆盖风险分类与责任机制
- 发现跨域合规存在互操作性差、执行难等三大漏洞
- 提出基于RDF/OWL的可机器验证合规模型,适配高风险场景
人工智能治理正从自愿伦理转向可执行的风险导向监管,但不同司法管辖区间的差异导致高风险AI运营者面临合规不确定性。本文构建欧盟、美国和中国三地的比较矩阵,涵盖风险分类触发条件、约束性义务、执法与问责机制,以及FAIR原则的实际落实程度。针对脑电图引导康复机器人、央行数字货币体系下的AI催收、新兴AI工厂中稀缺GPU资源分配三个高影响领域,基于原始法律文本与实施证据进行压力测试。研究发现三类共性缺口:互操作性要求薄弱、跨制度义务(AI+行业监管+数据保护)难以落地、关键数字基础设施使用场景治理不明确。为弥合执行差距,提出知识块(Knowledge Blocks)模式——基于资源描述框架/网络本体语言(RDF/OWL)、形状约束语言(SHACL)与溯源本体(PROV-O)的机器可验证合规构件,支持多法规环境下的设计即合规。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
AI governance is shifting from voluntary ethics to enforceable, risk-based regulation, yet cross-jurisdictional divergence creates compliance uncertainty for operators of high-stakes AI. We present a comparative matrix for the EU, US, and China that maps (i) risk classification triggers, (ii) binding obligations, (iii) enforcement and accountability mechanisms, and (iv) the degree to which FAIR principles are operationalised in practice. We stress-test the matrix on three high-impact domains: Electroencephalography (EEG)-guided rehabilitation robotics, AI-enabled debt collection in prospective Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC) ecosystems, and AI-driven allocation of scarce Graphics Processing Unit (GPU) resources in emerging AI Factory infrastructures. Using primary legal texts and implementation evidence, we identify three recurring gaps: weak interoperability mandates, difficult operationalisation of cross-regime obligations (AI + sector regulation + data protection), and under-specified governance for critical digital infrastructure use cases. To bridge the implementation gap, we outline Knowledge Blocks, a machine-checkable compliance artefact pattern based on Resource Description Framework/Web Ontology Language (RDF/OWL), Shapes Constraint Language (SHACL), and Provenance Ontology (PROV-O), enabling audit-ready compliance-by-design across multiple regimes.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。