对比四种3D重建方法,找出现实教育用全息模型的最佳方案
Comparative Evaluation of 3D Reconstruction Methods for Immersive Visualization of Laboratory Objects
- 用四类方法重建实验室物品的3D模型
- NeRF方法在透明/反光/低纹理物体上表现最优
- 适合想做增强现实教学的教师和研究者参考
本研究评估了当前3D重建方法是否能支持生成用于教育的逼真全息实验室物品模型。比较了四种方法:摄影测量、基于神经辐射场(NeRF)的方法、高斯溅射和激光雷达。这些方法用于生成常见实验器材的全息模型,并由研究生通过重复测量设计进行评估。参与者从形状、颜色、纹理和视觉缺陷等方面评分。总体来看,基于NeRF的方法在各类物体中均表现出最一致的高保真度,尤其在处理透明、反光或低纹理物品时优于其他方法。形状和颜色还原效果普遍优于纹理,表明某些视觉属性在教育全息模型中仍具挑战性。研究不仅揭示了各方法的优劣,还提供了一套可落地的沉浸式学习对象创建流程,可用于课前准备、空间推理训练及增强/混合现实教育环境中的学生参与。研究成果为教育工作者与沉浸式数字学习体验开发者提供了实用设计建议。
原文摘要 · Abstract (English)
In this study, we examined whether current 3D reconstruction methods can support the creation of realistic holographic representations of laboratory objects for educational use. In this regard, we compared four approaches: photogrammetry, a neural radiance field (NeRF)-based method, Gaussian splatting, and LiDAR. These methods were used to generate holographic models of common laboratory items and their fidelity was evaluated by graduate students. Participants assessed the models for shape, color, texture, and visual defects using a repeated-measures design. Across objects, the NeRF-based method produced the most consistently high-fidelity representations, particularly for transparent, reflective, or low-texture items that were difficult to capture with other approaches. Shape and color were generally reproduced more successfully than texture, suggesting that some visual properties remain more challenging to represent accurately in educational holograms. Beyond identifying the strengths and limitations of each reconstruction method, the study demonstrates a practical workflow for creating immersive learning objects that may support pre-laboratory preparation, spatial reasoning, and student engagement in AR/MR-based educational environments. These findings offer design-relevant insights for educators and researchers developing immersive digital learning experiences.
Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。