arXiv:2609.04962cs.AIcs.CL2026-09被引 1

理解是压缩的副产品,能预测才说明真懂。

Why We Care About Understanding: Competence through Predictive Compression

  • 用可预测性定义理解:掌握关系结构就能预测,无需重复存储。
  • 压缩是理解的表征影子,不是理解本身。
  • 人类理解追求简洁易传,因需信任与传承。

理解与压缩的关系为何重要?本文提出三个互为支撑的观点:第一,理解是识别可靠能力的高效代理,帮助我们判断该信赖谁、向谁学习;第二,理解意味着拥有可预测的领域关系模型,而可预测的内容无需单独存储,因此压缩成为理解的表征结果;第三,人类理解的可展示性与可传递性需求,推动其趋向原则性简洁。该框架既解释了压缩理论的吸引力与局限,也揭示了人工智能系统难以解释的本质原因。

原文摘要 · Abstract (English)

What is the relation between understanding and compression, and why does human understanding take such a heavily compressed form? Across information theory, machine learning, and AI research, a substantial tradition identifies understanding with compression-a thought captured in Gregory Chaitin's dictum that "comprehension is compression." Philosophers, by contrast, have characterized understanding in terms of grasping connections, giving explanations, and handling novelty. This paper bridges the two pictures through three interlocking theses. The first concerns the concept of understanding: it serves as an efficient proxy for a distinctive form of robust competence, enabling us to identify whom to trust and whom to learn from. The second concerns the state of understanding: to understand a domain is to possess a mental model of its relational structure that enables prediction, and what enables prediction enables compression, because what becomes predictable need not be stored separately. Compression is therefore not identical with comprehension, but its representational shadow. The third concerns the characteristically human form of understanding: the fiduciary and transmission functions highlighted by the first thesis impose pressures of demonstrability and transmissibility that drive human understanding toward principled simplicity. The resulting framework explains both the appeal and the limits of compressionist accounts of understanding while shedding light on the inscrutability of AI systems.

认知科学理解机制压缩可解释性

Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. PaperDance 不是 arXiv 官方产品;中文卡片由大模型生成,请以原文为准。